FREE DELIVERY for All Orders from $99. SHOP NOW!

Protein Bar vs Protein Shake: Which One For Your Goal?

by Ultimate Sup Staff on September 26, 2021

Protein bar vs protein powder, who will be the winner of this battle? Let's find out with Ultimate Sup Singapore.

Protein bars vs protein powders are both high in protein. But there comes a point when we must let go of one and choose another. It becomes more difficult to pick at times like these. So, it leads to the most important question in the battle of protein bars vs shakes.

TL;DR Protein Bar vs Shake: Which One For Your Goal?

Is a protein bar better than a protein shake? You can find the answer with this table below.

Protein Bar vs Shake - Ultimate Sup

Protein Bars

compare protein bars vs protein powder

As the name implies, these bars are high in protein in a variety of ways. Ingredients in these snacks include granola bars, whey protein, and other protein sources. As a result, they are a fantastic and healthy source of protein.

Protein Shakes

Protein shakes  - Ultimate Sup

You can make Protein shakes by combining protein powders with water or milk. Protein shakes can be beneficial during post-workout sessions. They are a high and direct source of protein. Their composition includes Whey Protein, Isolate, and other protein sources.

Protein Bar vs Protein Powder

To Reduce Hunger

Protein powders have a high protein content while being low in carbs and fats. Each serving should include at least 22 grams of protein to be a high-quality product. If the protein level is lower than this, the product may contain extra additives and/or sugar. This is not recommended.

Protein bars have more calories and carbohydrates than powders. They also have a higher fibre level, which is a good thing. It means protein bars will keep you full for longer than protein drinks. Protein bars have an advantage when it comes to feeling fuller than sipping shakes. 

The fact that protein bars have quite a higher calorie content does not imply they are high in calories. A quality protein bar has between 200 and 250 calories and 15 to 25 grams of protein per bar. But, try to avoid protein bars with high sugar content. 

To Support Muscle Growth

According to research, liquid forms of protein outperform solid versions when delivering amino acids to the bloodstream. Amino acids are the building blocks of protein. They are necessary for muscle growth and repair. A 2011 study published in the "British Journal of Nutrition" discovered that when an equal amount of protein was ingested in liquid and solid forms, the participants who took the liquid protein had higher levels of amino acids in their bloodstream for 30 minutes and four hours after ingestion. If you want to get amino acids from protein quickly to working muscles, it appears that a drink made with protein powder is the way to go. 

To Receive More Ingredient Value

Protein bars feature more added sugar and other filler carbohydrates than powders. Yet, you should be careful when using protein powders, too. They can contain artificial sweeteners, additives, and preservatives. If you must choose between a prepackaged protein bar vs shake, a blended mix of fresh fruit, milk, and pure protein powder is preferable to a store-bought bar. But, homemade protein bars made with pure protein powder, whole grains, nut butter, and dried fruit can be as good as a homemade protein drink.

When to Choose Protein Bars

Preworkout snack

Protein bars can provide a quick source of energy and protein before a workout, helping to fuel your muscles and prevent hunger during exercise.

On-the-go meal replacement

When you're in a rush and don't have time for a sit-down meal, protein bars can serve as a convenient and satisfying meal replacement option.

Postworkout recovery

The combination of protein and carbohydrates in protein bars makes them a suitable option for replenishing energy stores and supporting muscle recovery after a workout.

When to Choose Protein Shakes

Postworkout recovery

Protein shakes are quickly absorbed by the body, making them an ideal choice for post-exercise muscle recovery and growth.

Meal replacement

If you prefer a liquid meal option, protein shakes can be a convenient and customizable way to increase your protein intake.

Supplementing protein intake

When you need to boost your protein intake without consuming additional macronutrients, protein shakes offer a straightforward solution.

FAQ About Protein Bars vs Protein Shakes

Protein Bar vs Protein Shake: Which one is better for you

Protein Shake Before Or After Workout?

Protein is essential for muscle repair and rebuilding after exercise. Many people use protein drinks to help with this. But, according to a study, consuming a shake before or after workout makes no difference.

Protein Bar vs Shake: Which Can Assist Weight Loss?

For people seeking to lose weight, a meal replacement bar may be the best option. On a low-calorie diet? Make sure you get all of your nutrients in smaller meals throughout the day.

Can You Use Protein Shake And Bar Together?

Don't take protein shake and bar together. Instead, you should use each for different scenarios depending on personal preference. A well-made protein bar might be a convenient and healthy solution. Especially if you're searching for a snack to keep with you throughout the day. Protein bars are generally best if you're busy all day and need something quick. A protein shake may be preferable if you're looking for something simple to create at home. It will boost protein delivery after a workout.

Should You Use Protein Bar Or Shake For Breakfast?

You should definitely choose a protein shake for breakfast. It can deliver the whole nutritional value of a meal. You should only have a protein bar for breakfast if you're rushing out the door, rather than a cup of coffee. 

To conclude, Protein Bar vs Shake depends on your particular situation and requirement. A well-crafted dense Protein Bar will be helpful if you want something to last longer and fill your stomach with something that can support you throughout the day.

Protein Shakes, on the other hand, are the ideal solution if you want something you can make at home that will help you meet your protein needs and increase your muscle mass.

On our website, Ultimate Sup offers some of the best Protein Bars and Protein Powders. We provide a large selection of Protein bars and various nutritional supplements for you to choose from. Buy now with the best deals!

Related Articles: 


Please note, comments must be approved before they are published